Reasoning Practice · Starter

One quarter becomes the trend

Sales rose sharply last quarter. The new annual forecast assumes the same growth will continue, although the wider history is more variable.

Your decision

What should the forecast use as its starting point?

  1. A

    The most exciting recent quarter because it contains the newest information.

  2. B

    A broader distribution of comparable periods, then an explicit adjustment for current conditions.

  3. C

    The target required by the annual plan.

Show the best first move

B. A broader distribution of comparable periods, then an explicit adjustment for current conditions.

Why this move helps

Recent evidence matters, but it should be compared with a broader base rate. The adjustment should explain why this quarter is more informative than the rest.

Evidence still missing

  • Historical distribution of comparable periods.
  • Specific drivers of the recent change.
  • Evidence that those drivers will continue.

Evidence note

Availability may give the latest quarter extra weight. A genuine structural change can justify a large adjustment when supported by independent evidence.

Next action

Set the historical baseline and document each reason for moving away from it.

Best first lens

Availability Heuristic

Use the lens to ask a better question. It does not prove that a person or team has a cognitive bias.

Read the evidence review

Other defensible lenses

The situation may have more than one explanation.

Continue the path

Situation → skill → technique → action.

SituationForecasting under uncertainty

Make a forecast that can later be checked, updated and learned from.

Open situation →
SkillForecasting

You can produce forecasts that are easier to challenge, compare and learn from later.

Build this skill →
TechniqueBase-rate check

Compare a vivid case with the broader frequency or distribution that should inform the judgment.

Run the technique →

All reasoning scenarios